Or, the Man Who Turned Emotional Overthinking into a Literary Movement
By ABS, The Literary Scholar, who believes that if your candle flickers, your raven croaks, and your heart thuds a little too loudly—Poe probably wrote it first.
If American literature were a high school, Edgar Allan Poe would be the quiet kid in the corner, sketching skulls in his notebook, reciting poetry to ravens, and writing breakup letters in perfect iambic pentameter. He wouldn’t be invited to the prom, but he’d write such a haunting poem about it that the chaperones would start crying.
Born in 1809 and orphaned practically before the ink on his birth certificate dried, Poe was raised by the Allans (but not legally adopted—because why give him closure?) and promptly launched into a life of financial chaos, emotional turbulence, and literary genius wrapped in black lace and probable caffeine withdrawal.
Let’s be clear: Poe didn’t dabble in darkness. He bought real estate there. He made horror Gothic before Goths had wardrobes. He took grief, madness, premature burial, guilt, isolation, and dead women with excellent cheekbones—and turned them into America’s first true psychological thrillers.
Short Stories: Where Furniture, Feelings, and Floorboards All Collapse
Poe’s stories aren’t just scary—they’re unsettling in that elegant, “I suspect this furniture might have trauma” kind of way.
“The Fall of the House of Usher”
The house creaks. The family tree is more a tangled weed. The wallpaper is watching. And Madeline Usher pulls off the ultimate comeback by rising from the dead mid-funeral. It’s less real estate, more emotional liability.
Roderick, her twin, is basically anxiety in human form—sensitive to light, sound, and possibly air—and the house, being emotionally codependent, collapses the moment he dies.
Moral: Gothic mansions should come with a therapist.
“The Tell-Tale Heart”
The narrator insists he’s sane while he dismembers a man because of his eye. An eye. Just the eye. (Look, we’ve all had houseguests we wanted to kill, but this seems excessive.)
Cue beating heart, guilt trip, and dramatic confession. Spoiler: guilt will get you every time, especially if you have excellent hearing and no moral compass.
“The Cask of Amontillado”
This one’s about revenge. And wine. And extremely bad friendship. Montresor lures his drunk frenemy Fortunato into a cellar by dangling a vintage bottle, then walls him in alive.
Honestly, this is less horror and more Home Depot with homicide.
“The Masque of the Red Death”
Prince Prospero throws a costume party during a plague. (Sound familiar?) Each room is color-coded and symbolic—classic Poe. Then the embodiment of death crashes the party, uninvited, maskless, and unbothered, because metaphors don’t RSVP.
This is probably the only short story where interior design is fatal.
“The Raven”: Where Bird Meets Breakdown
“Once upon a midnight dreary”—and it only gets worse from there.
Our narrator, a man mourning his beloved Lenore (who is, of course, dead—Poe loved a good posthumous romance), is visited by a talking raven who answers every existential question with a soul-crushing “Nevermore.”
It’s not just a poem. It’s a slow emotional collapse in trochaic octameter.
The man wants hope. The raven gives mood swings. There’s grief, desperation, and enough repetition to make your therapist wince. By the end, the narrator is practically melting into his Victorian carpet while the raven settles in for a long-term rental on his soul.
Poe’s Life: A Plot Twist Wrapped in a Tragedy Inside a Whiskey Glass
Poe’s real life was only slightly less tragic than his fiction, and even that’s debatable. After being tossed between foster homes and university debts, he entered the literary world and wrote poetry that was too emotionally sincere for the 1830s and short stories that made people check under their floorboards.
He married his 13-year-old cousin Virginia (yes, really), adored her, and slowly watched her die of tuberculosis while composing odes to lost love and early graves. It’s as romantic as it is horrific—exactly what Poe excelled at.
When Virginia died, Poe was never the same. He wandered the country like a caffeinated ghost in his own story, trying to lecture on poetry, propose to women, and fight with literary rivals. He succeeded at all three, inconsistently.
Eventually, Poe died under mysterious circumstances in 1849, found delirious in someone else’s clothes, muttering nonsense. Theories range from alcohol poisoning to political kidnapping to “just being too Poe for this world.”
Why We Still Love Him: The Original Sadboi Gets the Last Word
Poe understood something vital: that the human mind is a haunted house, and sometimes, the monsters are self-made.
He took heartbreak and turned it into horror. He took fear and wrapped it in beauty. He stared into the abyss—and then published it in serial format.
Also, let’s not forget—he was the father of detective fiction with “The Murders in the Rue Morgue.” Before Sherlock, there was Dupin. Because why stop at horror when you can also invent crime procedurals?
ABS, The Literary Scholar, after accidentally reading The Black Cat alone at 1:30 AM with a flickering lamp and suspicious meows from outside the window, placed the book down slowly, exhaled theatrically, and muttered:
“Poe wasn’t writing horror. He was sending voice notes from the edge of emotional collapse.”
Then, with great ceremony and unnecessary dramatic flair, the scholar reached for a quill (which turned out to be a leaking fountain pen), and jotted in the margin:
“Let no man underestimate the literary power of a well-timed bird, a rotting house, and a conscience with excellent hearing.”
Signed,
ABS
The Literary Scholar
Who has now begun checking every wall for wine cellars and ravens with suspicious vocabulary.
Share this post / Spread the witty word / Let the echo wander / Bookmark the brilliance